The mark consists of a man dressed as a baker with a French mustache, orange skin, black and white eyes, a red bow tie, a yellow shirt, a white apron, black and white vertically striped pants, brown shoes, a white baker's hat, and brown hair; to the right of the man is the wording "The Buttermilk Drop", with the word "The" appearing in orange letters that shade from dark to light orange as it goes from top to bottom, the wording "Buttermilk Drop" appearing in orange letters shaded from dark orange to light orange and back to dark orange. The letter "O" in "DROP" is a brown glazed doughnut with orange icing spilling out of either side.